The banks have picked a fight they cannot win

View Gallery
4 Photos
The banks have picked a fight they cannot win
IMG_0054

Sure, they’re crazy colors, but it's still something everyone can wear. The effect was very translucent, with a silver, pearly finish to it. Under the lights, it sparkled—it really did. And no, you cannot do this at home.

The banks have picked a fight they cannot win
IMG_0042

We came up with five different shades: a mauve, a brown—which we were calling 'mink,' a beige—a very grey-ash color—and a flesh color, and a Nordic blond.

The banks have picked a fight they cannot win
IMG_0034

She added, "Marc asked me if I could come up with something kind of mink-y, old-lady, that had that kind of antique-y look about it.

The banks have picked a fight they cannot win
IMG_0027

It’s kind of a little nutty how this show has inspired people. I have clients calling from Paris, Japan

In the end, the State Bank of Pakistan (SBP) decided to be magnanimous to the banks, cutting its benchmark interest rate by a ‘meagre’ half a percentage point to 9%. Many bankers will no doubt have breathed a sigh of relief. The reality, however, is that their troubles have only just begun.

The irony is that the banks’ biggest weakness right now is something that they have implicitly thought of as their biggest strength: their absolute dominance of the country’s financial system. The funny thing about irony, however, is that it has a habit of being cruel. And the banks have been caught at the wrong end of a very cruel joke indeed.

The banks used to think they were effectively an oligopolistic cartel providing a service to depositors on poor terms. This allowed them to earn the highest net interest margins (the difference between what they pay out to depositors and what they charge borrowers) in the region, and among the highest in the world. The banks were not wrong. They really could afford to give a horribly bad deal to Pakistani depositors because, come on, where else can you put your money?

All was well, so long as they had a legally-tolerated oligopoly on the deposit-taking side. Even though the market was freer on the lending side, particularly for high-quality corporate borrowers, that deposit-side oligopoly kept the banks’ margins very comfortable. The Pakistani depositors were effectively being scammed, but who cared about them? The banks were happy. All was well. All could have stayed well. But, of course, it did not.

You see, making comfortable margins on their regular business was not enough for the banks, since it still involved having to do actual work. The easy profits, however, made the banks lazy. So when the federal government started borrowing insatiably from the banking system to finance its budget deficit, the banks were more than happy to lend. Who would not want to take in savings accounts at (what was then) 5%, and lend to the government at rates that at one point reached 15%? It was practically free money, with the added bonus of not having to set any capital aside against lending to the government.

But, as always in financial crises, the banks overdid their irrational exuberance for government debt. They have effectively turned the government into a monopoly borrower, which now accounts for more than half of all of their lending. And they had unfortunate timing: just as the relatively free market on the lending side of their balance sheet turned into a monopoly against them, the State Bank started to care (not much, but just a little bit) about depositors, raising the minimum interest rate on savings accounts.

Here is where things stand now: the banks have tried to reconstruct their oligopoly on the lending side to try to get higher rates from the government, but they face one problem: in any battle of market power between an oligopoly and a monopoly, the monopoly is always going to win.

And now the banks are stuck. They have lent so much to the government that they have crowded out the private sector almost completely, causing it to atrophy, along with their own corporate, commercial and retail lending workforce. This, paradoxically, means that they are even less tempted to lend to the private sector, and thus lend still more money to the government. The banks are trapped in a vicious cycle and do not have a way out.

The State Bank is trying to play the role of the referee, effectively by trying to shock the banks out of their reliance on government borrowing. It has raised deposit rates to increase their cost of funds, and continuously lowered lending rates to make the banks more desperate for higher rates from private sector lending. It also keeps pointing out that private sector lending is less risky when interest rates are low.

The SBP is also not lowering rates as low as it could (theoretically, lowering rates to 8% would be justifiable) because it knows that inflation will not stay as manageable as it has over the past year, and it does not want to increase the interest rate risk for companies looking to borrow money.

The central bank has done all it can to make this as easy for the banks as possible. Now it is up to them to try to dig themselves out of this hole.

Published in The Express Tribune, June 22nd, 2013

Farooq Tirmizi

CEO, Elphinstone

Farooq Tirmizi is the founder and CEO of Elphinstone, the financial services firm that operates SmartRupee.

No Comments Yet
  1. Homes for sale by ~ Video
    Homes for sale by Homes for sale by Lake Homes For Sale Thousands of Lakes and Lake Properties Click a state to begin your search » Lake Homes and Land For Sale Alabama Arkansas Connecticut Florida Georgia Idaho Iowa Kentucky Louisiana Maine Maryland Michigan Missouri Nebraska New York North Carolina Oklahoma Pennsylvania South Carolina Tennessee Texas Vermont Virginia Minnesota Wisconsin Other states coming soon Lake Cherokee, SC This is a summer “camp” that the family built over time back in 1969. It has no central AC or. Learn More » Lake Livingston, TX This is the one you have been …
    The post Homes for sale by ~ Video appeared first on Mortgage.

    Maine Finance

  2. portland auto auction

    Illinois state tax – Video
    Illinois House overrides Rauner vetoes of income tax increase, budget – Chicago Tribune Illinois state tax Illinois House overrides Rauner vetoes of income tax increase, budget With help from Republicans, House Democrats handed Gov. Bruce Rauner a political defeat — and handed residents an income tax increase. CBS 2’s Vince Gerasole reports from Springfield. With help from Republicans, House Democrats handed Gov. Bruce Rauner a political defeat — and handed residents an income tax increase. CBS 2’s Vince Gerasole reports from Springfield. SPRINGFIELD — Seeking to restore stability to a state government teetering on the abyss, lawmakers on Thursday turned …
    The post Illinois state tax – Video appeared first on Donate .

    St-loius Business
    BONUS 100 FREE DOFOLLOW Links SITE

    http://www.chengdusangna.org/space-uid-14137.html
    http://wotpaste.cascadianhacker.com/pastes/koAV6/?raw=true
    http://flauncher.ru/forum/
    http://www.lbscience.com/bbs/view.php?board_id=bbs53&no=47
    http://foodyind.com/boards/topic/340/praetorian-insurance-company

    http://www.canakkale.net.tr/canakkale-sehitlik-turu.html?unapproved=291658&moderation-hash=fae607d4f1022016c7ab738baf3d77b2#comment-291658
    https://nd-one.com/sleeping-tips/?unapproved=3481&moderation-hash=8321375d0e3fbd5c6b143d0f3da17197#comment-3481
    http://drjulioparra.com/ginecologo-en-ciudad-juarez/?unapproved=18485&moderation-hash=464ad500d0ea2253f16e7d20bcb980f1#comment-18485
    http://www.movieclose.com/blog/how-to-encourage-customers-to-leave-reviews/?unapproved=5399&moderation-hash=64d27b82b5825845379eeae513c392d4#comment-5399
    http://capesweden.com/shop/coatsophia-black/?unapproved=15404&moderation-hash=0984e28111b19fe1cee4a45b090d1b9b#comment-15404
    http://poorreds.com/2017/02/22/hello-world/?unapproved=17453&moderation-hash=f8d0da1ffa7527c73ce6966fdaddbf2f#comment-17453
    http://dutch-american.com/2014/05/10-reasons-you-need-proxima-theme/?unapproved=8573&moderation-hash=975b45421c0b9353a48227e65d7e2828#comment-8573
    http://seaenvgov.info.yorku.ca/?unapproved=26666&moderation-hash=3f5426f07770d0b7245f480bd3b02bbb#comment-26666
    http://landing.allinchicago.org/locations/michelles-ballroom/?unapproved=16242&moderation-hash=6296fc6bfdf150dcc0fcbb1c112d84c2#comment-16242
    http://w88tk.com/w88top-link-vao-nha-cai-w88-nhanh-nhat-2019-w88top-com/?unapproved=36565&moderation-hash=9334f003a8d55e4be175b99c79ca179c#comment-36565
    https://www.fededonbosco.org/es/blog/2018/02/27/animadores-convivencia-ajdb/?unapproved=9486&moderation-hash=a2dd09f2ceb20b0164500888657a17c8#comment-9486
    http://blazerformen.com/always-be-prepared/?unapproved=3831&moderation-hash=00c7a3b31958ffc588c253c2f3e82e38#comment-3831
    http://www.ximdesk.com/?unapproved=22524&moderation-hash=85c54fe5f99f9a5d6e3cff03ff0159a4#comment-22524
    http://daniellevangrondelle.com/dvgs-world-vlog-1/?unapproved=35075&moderation-hash=08ebc624f279ae1857d099f65bb3a2d2#comment-35075
    https://partyofcommunistsusa.org/espanol/th/
    http://www.purreskoven.dk/en-skruemaskine-er-et-must-at-have-liggende-i-huset/?unapproved=1948&moderation-hash=350021cc82274f27dfb76b752523627c#comment-1948
    http://www.blogbookworld.com/office-next-door-walks-on-the-keyboard?unapproved=116268&moderation-hash=3a74b60b1a192aee52a62b352c25dab1#comment-116268
    http://solarisin.com/security/?unapproved=10926&moderation-hash=ab60b30659f117553634a2149b69fd88#comment-10926
    https://blog.printed.com/trends-for-greeting-cards-in-2018/?unapproved=10123&moderation-hash=1d182c7fc039e0ed9853bc7735aedd03#comment-10123
    http://www.1stclassite.com/potential-capital-gain-at-the-skywoods/?unapproved=5232&moderation-hash=67ad83d5379753fbdec6b08c23d82074#comment-5232
    https://www.mps.com.mm/m_of_i/?unapproved=4767&moderation-hash=3ea9591588a4f4784d6ee7c8353e6339#comment-4767
    https://thepenguinempire.com/?unapproved=49618&moderation-hash=61fe79c2e629c7e4d9b0e205b854ff6d#comment-49618
    https://1088.cn/579.html?unapproved=958&moderation-hash=cf61e004bf338364ef7abeceafeae8fb#comment-958
    http://www.sindiquinze.org.br/2018/03/03/nota-de-pesar-nilton-dos-santos-de-lima/?unapproved=3375&moderation-hash=bdcd493a847fd97eb9d62c3ed3c893e5#comment-3375
    http://www.theninjaproxy.org/tv/a-fake-uk-ip-address/?unapproved=201086&moderation-hash=c296f4de06b27a137f4eda0d1cd01cb6#comment-201086
    http://shiroi0767.com/post-179/?unapproved=4101&moderation-hash=50f6d890aba8d406027258232e8b129f#comment-4101
    http://twoshoresrealty.com/2015/03/11/why-do-i-need-a-no-cost-buyer-broker/?unapproved=6688&moderation-hash=87331a205a11c7b5dbcb77c7950a69c3#comment-6688
    http://jenniferboylan.net/tim-kreider-in-nerve-on-new-york-and-home/?unapproved=12316&moderation-hash=80b87975d99626ed0565f79a77253327#comment-12316
    http://breezybudgets.com/2016/08/where-do-you-see-yourself-in-10-years/?unapproved=18009&moderation-hash=8c2d1a4c84f9000efaca6052cd9eed04#comment-18009
    http://www.villamoretti.com/special-offer-for-stays-7-days-and-more/?unapproved=4090&moderation-hash=8871807c97243024857d31dec5058f2c#comment-4090
    http://comealive.me/2013/the-power-of-magic/?unapproved=6678&moderation-hash=708bdcb8a56aa1e7cb2e75631d15cbe0#comment-6678
    http://www.sitemappro.com/how-to-simply-understand-sitemaps-of-your-blog/?unapproved=4194&moderation-hash=62999f9f01673c0cc743268cc3749f44#comment-4194
    https://erhard-wegscheid.de/allergie/?unapproved=672&moderation-hash=15c462ff23259b09789ab1601c0f9816#comment-672
    http://deceptiveplanet.com/sunday-morning/?unapproved=904&moderation-hash=6c467c4f78b8932a91794cd188ad6ec0#comment-904
    http://fablab.sr/2019/07/31/hello-world/?unapproved=551&moderation-hash=46e0a50b71232d6f03e3ab0057870869#comment-551
    http://toriqpriad.student.umm.ac.id/2016/09/01/8-keunggulan-jurusan-ti/?unapproved=6472&moderation-hash=a6767fcd9613cb93241c298e3509ec35#comment-6472
    http://socialesport.cat/cropped-cropped-cropped-img-20170429-wa0009-jpg/?unapproved=2737&moderation-hash=85f26bd5d2f2e73b8cc50f36698552e2#comment-2737
    http://www.greenzgardens.com.au/slideshow/tree-removal/?unapproved=24777&moderation-hash=5081981f11530458f3255aa4abcefd7d#comment-24777
    http://sjctech.com/articles/southwest-florida-business-data-cloud/?unapproved=17396&moderation-hash=742ad0ba8ac8b84dfaf313ee8b393bb1#comment-17396
    http://techtraveleatrepeat.com/sample-page/?unapproved=307405&moderation-hash=79e77dbbc3bcf0a79cdb8fd0ad231c32#comment-307405
    http://www.learnthesalesprocess.com/paint-industrial-equipment/?unapproved=4404&moderation-hash=8336446f9151480bdb323fa633f6f69e#comment-4404
    http://www.janeyoliphint.com/hello-world/?unapproved=26640&moderation-hash=8a8949656d4752515e92ef27c2dfe3d6#comment-26640
    http://ethicscommunity.com/?p=1&unapproved=8230&moderation-hash=fa63c91fa83fbf8428ec106053b9c0e8#comment-8230
    http://shanefilanireland.org/how-to-be-a-professional-singer/?unapproved=258721&moderation-hash=f4c8a92023a18f784e86be44019e9d41#comment-258721
    http://grupoceped.com.br/ola-mundo/?unapproved=587&moderation-hash=23766ac62891278c93f451d6febbfb07#comment-587
    http://curarlarosacea.senvlog.com/2015/01/22/como-se-diagnostica-la-rosacea/?unapproved=35557&moderation-hash=eef4ceec60f5670b7e93b34e01bfe30d#comment-35557
    http://www.choco.church/2016/11/03/voodoo-video/?unapproved=1079&moderation-hash=8eab70bef4f9787b94ef5e66c0ec27f5#comment-1079
    http://r2live.tv/demo-blog/?unapproved=83184&moderation-hash=3a5a9043e47e10e0391d350e1ac6ac2a#comment-83184
    https://reviewthisapp.com/day-one-the-daily-journal-app/?unapproved=6706&moderation-hash=c7233db3f7b5ae4cb1b99c06b8a4fc59#comment-6706
    https://memorythreads.com.au/school-ski-trip-australia-vs-new-zealand/?unapproved=1444&moderation-hash=bbbb418981af6771f419d73ce35ced6b#comment-1444
    http://galsinc.com/2014/12/hello-world/?unapproved=8502&moderation-hash=469f6049c5bcb8867ee9f5858d11b5b5#comment-8502
    http://www.josifidechen.com.br/2015/06/bonitas-da-vez-ingrid-e-maria-clara/?unapproved=257663&moderation-hash=f5d9b0979f2b6bd83e74feded32fe515#comment-257663
    http://tcmk-alania.ru/?page_id=965&unapproved=10545&moderation-hash=ea5d713ce394e8268d527d8107e893ab#comment-10545
    http://discoveringyourjoy.com/hello-world/?unapproved=11340&moderation-hash=5123980c17c5f186cb477fda3024bb50#comment-11340
    http://wso-au.org/ja/directors.html/wso-profile?unapproved=175647&moderation-hash=8027cf4ea0ed1999e689ac6005b85cb9#comment-175647
    http://spectrumantennas.com/products/s15b101-c2/s05d101-d6-2/?unapproved=417&moderation-hash=712302fb085721f627c24231479f8be4#main/#comment-417
    http://recycledlives.org/?unapproved=272939&moderation-hash=a3cc3c0ee0a4f841c58eeea8f29035c5#comment-272939
    https://i-kontur-ca.ru/?unapproved=622&moderation-hash=bae7113ad0cf525b5927897695c0720d#comment-622
    http://ggames.co/agen-situs-judi-online-terpercaya-indonesia-2018/?unapproved=99701&moderation-hash=94ccfbd8b15127655a5630f9a9022b25#comment-99701
    http://forum.mkadkm.ru/forums/topic/auto-accessories/
    https://buffalo.makerfaire.com/2018/04/18/welcome-tedx-buffalo-speaker-stage/?unapproved=2319&moderation-hash=ebab16b1636decbf08a668f6329ad628#comment-2319
    https://pendikehliyet.com/gbt-nedir-gbt-sorgulamasinda-hangi-bilgiler-cikar/?unapproved=28050&moderation-hash=c9a3740a324692cb2193ffbb536930aa#comment-28050
    https://shopandshout.com/product/pulling-oil-mouthwash-masigi/?unapproved=24822&moderation-hash=9333a7ad35004350cd1360804a516850#comment-24822
    http://epic-hc.com/post-388/?unapproved=7260&moderation-hash=7b2a2889d504f938f0a9fb69548cf25c#comment-7260
    http://www.alpc.kr/188752?unapproved=511&moderation-hash=ce506d09886c706403e8f7c1d6659048#comment-511
    http://aaue.biz/hello-world/?unapproved=10328&moderation-hash=9a67da07f030ff84d98f3826424f8b16#comment-10328
    https://abacusan.hu/tehetseg/verseny/allam-polgar/hello-world/comment-page-1/?unapproved=11010&moderation-hash=311b1f3a8f60cd2029a9563783be9425#comment-11010
    https://jmllandscaping.com/site-improvements-drainage-and-grading/?unapproved=18502&moderation-hash=9a845a5ed283bbdc0b7d82b891053caf#comment-18502
    http://hairinthebag.com/blog/how-to-use-hair-extensions-clip-in/?unapproved=330947&moderation-hash=79c0b402d678db735fa49a529342c9b8#comment-330947
    http://photo78.vn/working-on-a-new-project-multi-family-passive-house/?unapproved=14460&moderation-hash=0e4c63a13fedf536d148c22dfb675c25#comment-14460
    https://dashcontrol.com/new-head-office-and-showroom/?unapproved=43593&moderation-hash=d89ad38c9d082b023da663e0a5404f0c#comment-43593
    http://like-no-udder.com/hello-world/?unapproved=26522&moderation-hash=439440af852988b050cc6d54a0e98766#comment-26522
    http://fenster-dekorplast.de/zweifach-oder-dreifachverglasung-was-ist-besser?unapproved=3775&moderation-hash=f128a2ce65634a3b2451fa12c8e3209d#comment-3775
    http://www.sallywisbeynutrition.co.uk/recipe-tomato-soup/?unapproved=26198&moderation-hash=5868c37ad3726731d488fa4824ba518f#comment-26198
    https://akrceramics.com/pottery-tools/?unapproved=6850&moderation-hash=bb0253f722a3c95100511fe741cbf9b9#comment-6850
    http://www.darteventi.com/anul-didactic-2010-2011/?unapproved=1124&moderation-hash=17427e6b5d01769b350aa094bcebf92a#comment-1124
    http://www.beyond-borders.nl/nieuws/maar-liefst-8-puppen/?unapproved=9653&moderation-hash=b9c54d6c6bdf3c3fa6f9cf40c7a5e7ec#comment-9653
    http://blog.iamnfrancis.com/mixtape-monday-sunday-afternoon-bus-ride/?unapproved=12455&moderation-hash=693a108b6ac739851cfb84495b139e97#comment-12455
    http://miafratinofoundation.com/qa-with-jacinta-making-the-foundation-happen/?unapproved=8398&moderation-hash=1abd2089d48382317827909c145874c0#comment-8398
    http://forbesrichlistfacts.com/2015/05/li-ka-shing/?unapproved=103806&moderation-hash=ec9c2a1c830d763e19c3c9dfd75c8871#comment-103806
    https://www.casinovilag.com/try-an-online-casino-out-before-you-join/?unapproved=12406&moderation-hash=ec528ef97205a79b732666e51664f0df#comment-12406
    http://otulicmame.pl/mama-pelna-milosci/?unapproved=3991&moderation-hash=8fbf3e7137f00ab5be3cc14cbe16f638#comment-3991
    https://cryptoforum.online/showthread.php?t=1150&p=21318#post21318
    http://girlsparkle.com/farmers-markets/?unapproved=28482&moderation-hash=7c343acab19c007b9ba2dc3b0b6e0af5#comment-28482
    https://www.voetbalgokken.net/voorbeschouwing/psv-eindhoven-roda-jc/?unapproved=2820&moderation-hash=f15e1e514fef1d6638d4c13edfe160cc#comment-2820
    http://www.gmcconsultores.com.mx/wp/en-equilibrio-tus-finanzas-regreso-a-clases/?unapproved=25827&moderation-hash=73175e284cbe9caa8e8f06b49a5ed3c4#comment-25827
    https://vstfitness.com/personal-trainer-review/?unapproved=5662&moderation-hash=ba72661c7b1b4c93ba0ac039417edf38#comment-5662
    http://squirrelscience.net/blog/posted-the-pen-is-about-14-5-cm-long/?unapproved=7822&moderation-hash=034d5783588b13566d36fc3121d6ee2f#comment-7822
    http://telemarktredesign.no/skreddersydde-produkter/?unapproved=3965&moderation-hash=6278082d5f140c3cd0099477003f70a5#comment-3965
    http://www.lanuitelectroswing.com/minimatic-interview-dun-grand-monsieur/?unapproved=26635&moderation-hash=f779d1efd0eb92fa4f67ad663698d941#comment-26635
    http://boxermaduane.ch/a-la-veille-des-premiers-departs/?unapproved=4862&moderation-hash=ef6f3c2557b9d76db2fb5b072ff6f763#comment-4862
    http://www.accordo.com.br/2016/07/construcao-civil/?unapproved=28839&moderation-hash=08c9dcdd3a8dbe72666e9ee318f173f9#comment-28839
    http://dailysport.co.ke/2018/04/08/winston-churchill-cup-simon-njogu-on-top/?unapproved=528096&moderation-hash=633f061cbe81a3536e3f348d4a514148#comment-528096
    http://www.jaalenews.com/2016/01/24/milatariga-kenya-oo-yaaban-iyo-laamaha-amaanka-kenya-oo-lahowl-galiyay/?unapproved=59321&moderation-hash=6d86243b44a695fee3ecaed8bf74883e#comment-59321
    https://fontanseguridad.es/robos-en-comunidades-de-vecinos/?unapproved=4735&moderation-hash=2b33d8a9de9e3626c26cc92a0ee7c83e#comment-4735
    http://www.babybestpitch.com/its-positive-d/?unapproved=1920&moderation-hash=d9338e89fb55d8647b16ec15466736c3#comment-1920
    https://blog.inox-us.com/inox-hb-at-liberty-fairs-lv2018/#comment-32932
    http://www.ytub.nl/2017/03/29/el-bebe-jefazo/?unapproved=8603&moderation-hash=8fde1144510b50e7410c9627058ff797#comment-8603
    http://makeitallen.com/blog/plumbing-maintenance-tips-for-restaurant-owners/?unapproved=3862&moderation-hash=fa2bae373d43152de9143748e213cfc3#comment-3862
    http://blooming-talent.de/hello-world/?unapproved=11024&moderation-hash=8c8e58193bf648ff94372a81fce5c15f#comment-11024

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.